Targeting Cramer

It didn’t take Murdoch long. Barron’s went after Cramer this past weekend:

Cramer is unapologetic about his self-promotion, but he acknowledges his bad calls, too. What he hasn’t done is tell his viewers the overall score for his two-plus years of Mad Money picks. When he hits his “Buy Buy Buy” sound-effect button, can viewers expect market-walloping results?
In trying to figure that out, we came across YourMoneyWatch.com, a Website started by Michael McGown, a retired securities analyst who worked for several major brokerage firms. McGown started the site not long after the show started, and says Cramer sent a complimentary e-mail after noticing it. McGown counts only Cramer’s clear and unconditional Buy recommendations, following a sensible set of rules. McGown tracks the stock until Cramer says sell. “As a person watching the show,” says McGown, “I think it’s a fair way to rate him.”
Over two years, YourMoneyWatch has tracked 1,300 Mad Money picks. It’s this tally that shows Cramer’s stocks lagging behind the Dow and the S&P 500. This year, Cramer’s done better. McGown’s data show his picks up 3.2%, while the S&P is up 2%; the Dow, 4.9%; and the Nasdaq, 3.7%. CNBC says the YourMoneyWatch data, as well that of Cramer’s Mad Money Website, are “not authoritative.”
Hoping to get Cramer’s advice on how to measure his Mad Money picks, I called him a few weeks ago. He tore into me. “I’ve never read a single article that I thought wasn’t a massive distortion of what the show’s all about,” he said. When I said I just wanted to see Mad Money’s record, he replied: “I’ve never seen an analysis that I’ve regarded as honest, and I doubt yours is any different.”

Posted by on August 20th, 2007 at 11:23 am


The information in this blog post represents my own opinions and does not contain a recommendation for any particular security or investment. I or my affiliates may hold positions or other interests in securities mentioned in the Blog, please see my Disclaimer page for my full disclaimer.