At Least Microsoft Thinks Microsoft is Cheap

There’s been heavy speculation that Microsoft (MSFT) is going to sell debt this year in order to buy back its stock and pay dividends. This would be a fascinating move and it shows just how unusual the current market is.
Whatever you think of Microsoft and its future, the company currently generates an astounding amount of cash. According to the latest statement, MSFT has a cash balance of over $36 billion which works out to $4.22 per share. Their long-term debt is roughly $6 billion. Shareholders, not surprisingly, want some of that loot.
The problem with Microsoft’s huge bank account is that it’s mostly held overseas. As a result, MSFT is going to try and raise as much money as possible without affecting its AAA rating. One source said they could probably take in $6 billion.
When debt is expensive and equity is cheap, the rational choice for companies is to do exactly what Microsoft is doing—issue debt to buy stock. I’d be very curious as to the interest rate MSFT would land.
The company currently pays a 13-cent quarterly dividend which comes out to an annual yield of 2.07%. The dividend, however, is fairly modest compared to Wall Street’s current earnings estimate of $2.36 per share.
In May 2009, MSFT went to the bond market and floated $2 billion at 2.95% for 5-year notes, $1 billion at 4.2% for 10-year notes and $750 million at 5.2% for 30-year bonds. I think they can easily get much lower than that today.
Microsoft is in the lucky position of having its debt rated AAA by Moody’s and S&P. That saves them a lot of money in borrowing costs. Last year, the software had an amazing $22 billion in free cash flow. About half of that came from the United States.
Of course, there’s the question of whether or not a company should be trying to make money by shifting pieces of paper around. As David Merkel says, “Why pay money for financial engineering? Better you should look for genuine organic growth.” He’s got a good point. When I invest in a company I want them to do what they do best. Let me worry about if their stock is a good buy or not.
Since FY 2006, Microsoft has spent over $78 billion on share buybacks and the stock has done nothing but go down. The company is currently in the middle of a $40 billion buyback program that runs through 2013.
The other option is for Microsoft to spend its cash on acquisitions. Still, we’re back to the company being a money manager more than a software firm. To quote Biggie Smalls, “Mo Money, Mo Problems.”

Posted by on September 14th, 2010 at 10:23 am


The information in this blog post represents my own opinions and does not contain a recommendation for any particular security or investment. I or my affiliates may hold positions or other interests in securities mentioned in the Blog, please see my Disclaimer page for my full disclaimer.